Previous Next

Photo: mt 23

Sometimes people confuse their travel bucket lists with their grocery lists, talking about cities as if they were check marks. Unlike remembering to pick up milk, you cannot say you’ve ‘done’ a city simply because you spent a weekend there. What you actually mean is you’ve already been there, and that given a limited window for travel time, you would prefer to go to a city you haven’t seen before.

But when we say we’ve ‘done’ a city, it sounds like we have depleted the place of its experiences; it’s as if nothing of excitement remains. Certainly we could return and hike the nearby mountain we didn’t have time for, or rendezvous with the barfly we befriended last time, but if we’re already on the road, the logical tendency is to eschew this strategy in favor of new horizons.

They may have managed to complete the skeleton of the picture.

But can you ever truly ‘do’ a city? You can ‘do’ all the tourist attractions, but that’s not the actual place. Experiencing the local culture, meeting the inhabitants, and finding fun new corners of the city aren’t like loading bars; at no point have you completed 42% of the city, like some quest in a video game. Cities are living, breathing entities, and the exact same place is an entirely different creature at different times of the year, with different people, at different points within the national timeline.

For example, Berlin in the winter is a completely distinct place from Berlin in the summer — its abundant green spaces change considerably when coated in snow, and the city’s music scene retreats into dark basements to hide from the cold. It’s enough to make you question whether it’s even the same place.

Beyond the weather, there is also the provincial component. Different neighborhoods of the same city will yield wildly different impressions among travelers. The hippy bastion of Christiania in Copenhagen is a vital part of the city, but it’s certainly not representative of the Copenhagen at large. The downtown section of any metropolis is a busy hubbub of financial employees, tourists, and iconic buildings, but it isn’t as ‘authentic’ as the outskirts, where the majority of the actual citizenry make their homes and their livings. Immigrant populations, fluctuating housing prices, and proximity to nature or water all color neighborhoods in their own way.

The city that many travelers claim to have ‘done’ is often nothing like the miniscule ‘recommended’ or ‘historical’ section they never ventured out of. Pardon my metaphor, but if the city was a Connect the Dots picture and their path was the pencil, they may have managed to complete the skeleton of the picture, yet there remain many dots still unconnected that would flesh out a fuller and even more beautiful design.

Perhaps the factor that influences how you see a city the most is your travel partners or hosts. Samuel Johnson once said, “When a man is tired of London, he is tired of life; for there is in London all that life can afford.” He’s right. Big cities like that are able to offer up whatever you’re looking for, and so it follows that you’ll see a different city depending on what you’re looking for. Traveling to London with a foodie will result in an entirely different weekend than one with a fashionista, history buff, or clubgoer.

I spent my week there with visiting family, which meant we spent far more time sitting at restaurants and on the red tourist bus than I would have liked. Yet that’s the side of London that best fit the company, given that shepherding four boys of varying ages and temperament through back alleys in search of something new is not an appetizing task for any troupe leader.

And these are just in reference to traveling through the city. One could argue that living in a city is the only way to truly understand the place, as then you’re tied into its livelihood through consciousness of the specific laws, civil unrest, gossip. Even then, there’s no way to know when you’ve ‘done’ the city — depending on the person and their preferences, it could take months, years, or a lifetime to see all they want to see. I’m certain that even if I ate out at a different cafe in Barcelona every day for every single meal, it would take years to taste them all. Once again, this process isn’t one that’s well represented by a loading bar.

I’ve been consistently amazed at the breadth of opportunity the same city can provide to different people. The same neighborhood might be considered the premium place for street food to one person, the sketchy part of town that’s best avoided to another, the best place to grow up to a third, or simply overrated to the general public. It all depends on who you ask, and what they say depends on what they’ve seen for themselves. Nobody is wrong, necessarily; but it’s only once you put all of them together that a complete picture begins to form.

Think about your hometown. Would you say you have ‘done’ it? How many new, hidden aspects of your city have you happened on by chance, months or years into your stay there? I’m all for pushing on to new horizons, but keep this in mind the next time you dismiss a travel destination you spent a few days in way back when. Chances are you aren’t going to see the same parts, with the same people, at the same time of year…chances are you won’t be returning to the same place.

Travel Illusion

 

About The Author

Corey Breier

Corey Breier is an avid explorer of both the wilderness and the web. His heart remains in the SF Bay Area of his youth, although his current home base is Barcelona. Read his current exploits at spainwhatup.tumblr.com.

  • Alouise Dittrick

    Yes. Completely agree. I’ve lived in the same city for 28 years, and I still haven’t done it all. Meanwhile when my family went to Cancun a couple years back my dad says he’s “done” Cancun. What? We spent 90% of our vacation on the resort, and one day at Chichen Itza. If I haven’t done my own hometown there’s no way I can completely check off any other place I’ve been to.

  • Carlo Alcos

    Well put. It has always been a pet peeve of mine, when people use that “done” word. But it is exactly that, a reference to a list that can be checked off by country counters. I want to hear about experiences, (what did you learn?) not the number of places one has been to. That tells me nothing.

  • Jessie Wych

    Yes. I live in a Southwester “destination” town. If you think about checking this one off your list, know we are watching you and laughing.

  • Brandon Krapf

    I get the author and the commenters want to project themselves as “in-depth” and “intrinsic” and understanding of how a city or country is hyper-dynamic. But seriously, I use the term all the time. Why do I used that term? Because it takes to damned long to say “What [I] actually mean is [I've] already been there, and that given a limited window for travel time, [I] would prefer to go to a city [I] haven’t seen before.”

    Does that make sense? If you do not like the operative term “done” then find another one. Until then I , as a very experienced and frequent traveler & expat will use that term, particularly when I say to a someone “where should I go” and they say “Paris” and I respond with “nah, I did Paris back in 2005″ and then they say to me “I hate when you say that, You were there for a week”. And I say “well you lived in the US for 25 years and what do you say to that? You say “I think I know America, let me expand out a bit”. Well of course you can never truly know America because it is huge and dynamic and changing. So if you can never really “know” or “do” a location as it is always changing then how do you refer to having “been there done that”?

    More so, even if it was not linguistic issue, it is a subjective issue (as you pointed out yourself, maybe you are a foodie or touristy type, or art fan) so perhaps for that person they did everything they want to do, ergo, they “did” that city.

    Keep your elitist travel attitude to your self – someone will always have spent more time in a place and less time in a place than you – it is completely subjective (not to include the commenter below who referenced their father at the resort lol) So when you travel, travel for yourself, if you saw every bar or statue in Paris and that is your thing, then so be it, you did it – as have I in 40 countries so far.

  • Mac Witmer

    Corey, fantastic food for thought. While travelling abroad, I too, find myself disappointed by the iconic attractions a city has to offer. My fondest memories are in the outskirts of town, things we discovered– not conquered. Keep writing. You have quite a talent!

I'd like to know what people at the bottom of the peak were thinking.
Being in a place didn’t mean that I would be able to give insight into what it’s...
The DC I hate is not my new zip code but a new set of fantasies I’ve adopted.
Here are 25 volunteering opportunities to experience before you die. What would you add...
They made it strangely harder for me to see the Barbados I had come to find.
Summer is coming. Time to hit the beach...but which one?
You can't just say, "Brett Dennen's 'When I Go' is the way I wanna go out always."
Straight out of Tijuana, Los Macuanos work in a scary genre of beats known as "trival."
Experience the joy of singing in the car with your kids
Georgia will become safe for travelers long before the image of Russian tanks rolling...