Is building golf courses in the desert a smart idea? The GreenBiz blog says no.

“That’s one biiiiggg sand trap.” Photo: bedoika

Matador’s long been interested in the big picture impact of Dubai’s hyperdevelopment on human communities and the environment.

But since we’re more likely to be found surfing on Spain’s North Coast, boating Big Sky country in Montana, or trekking in Bhutan, we’re a bit out of the loop when it comes to golfing in Dubai.

Fortunately, the folks over at the GreenBiz blog have been keeping tabs on the topic. In a recent article, “Desert Golf Courses Symptomatic of Arab Region’s Larger Water Problems,” writer Tilde Herrera indicated that the Arab region’s 16 golf courses–at least three of which are in Dubai–may be successful attracting a certain group of tourists, but are likely to generate a poor long-term return on investment.

The reason?

Each of the golf courses uses an average of 1.16 million cubic meters of water annually, enough water to meet the daily needs of 15,000 local residents.

As an arid, desert region, Dubai and its neighbors already face considerable challenges related to water. But with the plan to expand the total number of golf courses to 40 in the coming years, the water problems the region faces are likely to grow exponentially.

Given the tendency toward short-term planning rather than a long-term cost-benefits analysis, the Arab Forum for Environment and Development, cited by Herrera, signals that the region is at a critical turning point with respect to the environment and sustainability.

The news also poses challenges to conscientious travelers: How do our recreational activities affect local environments and local people?

Community Connection:

Live in Dubai? Matador’s looking for a local correspondent! You can read about the details here.

And speaking of sports, we’ll soon be launching MatadorSports! Keep coming back to MatadorNetwork for guides to outdoor activities that have low environmental impact!

About The Author

Julie Schwietert

Julie Schwietert Collazo is a writer, editor, researcher, and translator currently in New York, formerly of Mexico City and San Juan. She is Matador's managing editor and is the lead faculty member of MatadorU's travel writing program.

  • http://www.evaholland.com Eva

    Great post, Julie. The UAE’s obviously an extreme example, but I think golf courses are a pretty poor use of resources any time, any where.

    Now, you could make the argument that any recreational activity that consumes resources is, technically, a waste — since it doesn’t provide food or shelter to anyone — but I think sports can be an important part of a full life and are worth a bit of consumption.

    Golf, though, is so demanding — in terms of land and water use, not to mention the damage done by all the chemicals used to keep those greens shiny — relative to the number of people who get to partake, that I think it’s absolutely one of the most wasteful sports out there. I get a little sick when I see massive, fenced-off, private golf courses on tiny Caribbean islands, with a maximum of 72 rich people using them at once (18 holes, flights of four golfers, right?) while local kids cram into alleys and tiny patches of grass to play cricket.

    (Oh, and I might also have a chip on my shoulder because the one time I tried golf, I really, really sucked at it. Ha!)

    Okay, end of rant. :)

    • dfinepa

      Nice article Julie. Hopefully when push comes to shove on the water-front, the local authorities will see sense.

      Eva – you are right on with the Caribbean island point too – I have some family in Bermuda and you can hardly enjoy a view on the entire island without seeing a flag and bunker somewhere in the vicinity. They have nine courses on their 21 square miles of land…

  • http://thelonglayover.blogspot.com Carlo

    Very sad, selfish, and short-sighted.

  • http://wayworded.blogspot.com/ Hal

    I heard somewhere that one of the most dangerous jobs on the planet is golf course landscaper. They use so many chemicals to ensure the greens live up to their name…I think their life expectancy was something like 50!

    So yeah, I think I’ll stay away from golf courses!

Sustainability →

Demands on UK and European fisheries are making them less productive and putting both the...

Sustainability →

Conservacion Patagonica is putting together a protest at the Chilean embassy in in San...

Sustainability →

In 2008, the world consumed a whole lotta water wrapped in plastic.

Trip Planning →

Now that Dubai is officially home to the tallest building in the world, the Babel analogy...

Sustainability →

Online Education breaks down everything you need to know about bottled water in a few...

Sustainability →

Feeling thirsty? So are millions of other people.

Trip Planning →

"Go, let us build us a city and a tower, whose top may reach unto heaven..."

 

Despite being in the news more or less constantly, the Middle East is an area that most...