Previous Next

Photo: soaringbird

In honor of the International Day of the Woman, municipal authorities of Juarez, Mexico organized their first Miss Captive Beauty Pageant at the Cereso Prison on Tuesday.

FIFTEEN OF THE prison’s 600 inmates competed for titles such as Miss Captive Beauty, Miss Photogenic, and Miss Elegance, sporting elegant donated dresses in competition for cash prizes. Cecilia Juarez, 22, imprisoned on charges of drug trafficking and awaiting sentencing, was crowned Miss Captive Beauty.

Organizers of the event touted it as a rehabilitative effort to raise the women’s self esteem, and contestants interviewed for Mexican television said it helped to break up the monotony of prison life and that they enjoyed dressing up and being outside.

It’s an interesting subversion of the traditional beauty pageant that demands a mirage of perfection in both traditional “beauty” and personal life, and often ends in tearful apologies when some aspect of the beauty queen’s life falls outside of that fairytale dimension.

And certainly if any society is seeking to have effective rehabilitative prisons that address the issues behind criminality rather than simply serving as revolving doors, creative programs can be a step in that direction.

“And mostly, I’m thinking of the rest of the women of Juarez, Mexico.”

But I can’t help but get a disturbed feeling from watching news reports that zoom in and out on women’s bodies. I’m having trouble making the connection between rewarding a select few prisoners based on their looks and celebrating womanhood. And mostly, I’m thinking of the rest of the women of Juarez, Mexico.

Since the early ‘90s, hundreds of women in this border town have been killed, raped, or “disappeared” and never been found. These women were poor, many of them on their way to work in the maquiladora (sweatshop) industry, and the police have been notoriously dismissive towards the pleas of family members to investigate the cases, with 177 state officials deemed negligent in their handling of the investigations.

Recent measures by the Mexican government indicate that they are hearing some of the outcry, but much remains to be done in the way of true justice and reform. This is compounded by the fact that Juarez is a border city that has been one of the biggest casualties of the drug war.

This is a place where women were often blamed for their own murders, their characters attacked, and their sexual habits questioned, and where flyers would go up with safety tips for women such as not wearing provocative clothes or skirts that are too short.

I wonder whether the well-meaning officials behind Miss Captive Beauty are playing into the same kinds of paradigms that have turned marginalized women into disposable objects, ones not even worthy of a murder investigation, or a look into the complex conditions that drive their involvement in drug trafficking.

I also wonder whether this is indicative of attitudes in Juarez or if it’s just simply that the problematic aspects of beauty pageantry are made more aware because it’s removed from its usual arena and placed in the context of prison. And I also wonder whether I even have a right to question something that seems, at least from media reports, to be happily welcomed by the women of the prison themselves.

What do you think? Is a beauty pageant at a prison in Juarez a move forward or backwards?

Community Connection:

For more on Mexico and border issues, please read our interview with author David Danilo: “Back in 1848?: A Closer Look at the US/Mexico Border.”

Culture + Religion


 

About The Author

Gabriela Garcia

Gabriela Garcia is a freelance writer who splits her time between New York, Miami, and, as often as possible, the world. In between pondering the universe, she enjoys Jivamukti yoga, camping, and chance encounters with fascinating people. She loves interacting with fellow travelers on Twitter.

  • http://www.expatheather.com Heather Carreiro

    Gabriela, you’ve raised some excellent points. I’m not exactly sure what to think of this. I mean for the women in the it would surely be something to break the monotony of the daily routine, but is it re-enforcing a fetish for the “captive beauty”?

    Seriousness aside, that videographer must have been a man and one with a ‘Sir Mix-a-Lot” complex…

  • http://milesofabbie.com Abbie

    I would like to hope that the authorities at the prison were well-intentioned, but I agree that this may not be the best way to celebrate womanhood.

  • Somchai

    There was a similar contest in Cambodia for victims of landmines. The Cambodian government cancelled it and there were a lot of bad feelings from advocacy groups for landmine victims.

    I’l have to admit I’m not much of a beauty contest watcher myself, just not my kind of thing, but to a lot of women getting all made up and stuff is what they like to do. If it makes them happy I’m all for it.

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/08/03/cambodia-bans-miss-landmi_n_249763.html

  • http://matadortrips.com/ Hal Amen

    I agree that the juxtaposition of “captive” and “beauty” is not a positive one. At all.

  • Maria

    Great article and topic! The message is a contradictory one. Many of these women are trapped in every sense of the word. I don’t view beauty contests as the correct message. I think teaching them to discover their inner uniqueness, and learning how to apply it in so many areas of their lives would be more productive in the end.

  • http://www.blackeyesoncinema.wordpress.com Shadae Smith

    I don’t know how to feel about it either. How is the pagent set up? Are all the women celebrated in someway? Are they given outlets too express how they feel or are they being trained to be more “respectable”. Are women moderating and monitoring the growth of these women or are men?

Violence remained at a distance, a story told, a finger pointed.
I asked my translator to please tell these women that my heart is with them.
A mob of giddy housewives, plenty of tequila, a secondhand wedding gown, an orgy's worth...
A marathon Holy Week drive across Mexico is a chance to ponder: what is "lo maximo" for a...
Learning more than just how to cook in Teotitlan del Valle, Oaxaca.
As you look at these photos, I hope you won't just think about Mexican women. I hope...
All that kissing! One cheek and then the other, the two faces weaving dangerously close,...
The first time it happened to me, I thought it was a fluke - a creative cashier with...
Unfortunately, the nature of South Africa’s past, and the diversity of its population...
Project Explorer is a nonprofit organization that produces free, online travel series for...
Things can get lost in translation when a typical gesture from your country means...