Photo: elisfanclub

Earlier today, Fran Golden, co-author of Frommer’s Alaska Cruises & Ports of Call and guest editor of USA Today’s Cruise Log Blog, reported that US Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton has proposed “more controls on tourism in Antarctica.”

Concerned about travelers’ safety and environmental integrity in the remote and frigid, region, Secretary Clinton’s proposal included:

“…new requirements on the number of lifeboats on ships…,[m]andatory limits on the size of cruise ships sailing in Antarctica and the number of passengers [who] can be brought ashore…, [as well as] one guide for every 20 visitors ashore.”

Signatory members of the Antarctic Treaty and the Arctic Council received Secretary Clinton’s proposal positively, but it remains to be seen if the policies advocated by the US will be implemented, especially if Antarctic tour operators have their say.

Antarctica has no government and does not belong to any country, though it is a temporary home to researchers from all over the world. To date, many of the continent’s tourism policies have been agreed upon by the Treaty and Council nations, which have little, if any, authority to exercise enforcement.

What kinds of policies might benefit Antarctica, how should tourism policies for the continent be developed, and how might they be enforced? Share your ideas in the comments below.

COMMUNITY CONNECTION:

Believe it or not, Matador has an Antarctica destination expert! rico nico, originally from San Francisco, California, worked in the dining room at McMurdo Station for five months. About the experience, he writes:

My experience at McMurdo was one my life’s highlights. I commonly describe it as “living on another planet.” Of the many oddities, a few of the most profound are: the absence of children, not seeing the stars or the moon (daylight 24/7), and the monochromatic landscape. Everything is white, grey, or blue. Seeing green and smelling the earth when I came home was incredible!

Another huge perk: included in your free/paid, trip to Antarctica is a return-when-you-wish trip to New Zealand (your departure point for the ice). I’ve been down there twice and am happy to make suggestions about traveling the islands–from how to buy a car to what trails to backpack.

Sustainability World EventsEnvironment
 

About The Author

Julie Schwietert

Julie Schwietert Collazo is a writer, editor, researcher, and translator currently in New York, formerly of Mexico City and San Juan. She is Matador's managing editor and is the lead faculty member of MatadorU's travel writing program.

  • http://www.lolaakinmade.com Lola

    Yeh I heard this on CNN today and had mixed feelings.

    Definitely understand the environmental impact and safety of travelers angle.

    The selfish part of me really wants to go to Antarctica someday :)

  • Julie Schwietert

    Lola-

    I definitely think that policies put in place for safety and environmental reasons are positive–somewhat akin, I guess, to the Galapagos. What really interests me about this particular news bite, though, is the fact that compliance is likely to be voluntary rather than mandatory, as it seems that no single country or entity really has the resources or the authority to exercise jurisdiction or regulatory power over compliance. I’m not sure there’s any other place in the world where a situation exists quite like this one.

  • http://www.matadorabroad.com Tim Patterson

    I chose not to go to Antarctica last year. The contrast between the reality of the place and the luxury of the tourism is just too weird. Antarctica is a destination one should have to earn.

  • http://www.evaholland.com Eva

    Hmm. As far as voluntary participation in the new safety/etc restrictions go, maybe tour operators that refuse to adhere to the guidelines should be on the hook for any costs associated with a rescue effort?

    Also: no single nation may control Antarctica, but all of these operators have home ports. I’m sure with some creativity (and, of course, the willingness to make this stick) governments could cooperate to control operators that aren’t willing to be reasonable.

    As far as Antarctica itself goes, I’ve always sort of felt like it’s the only part of the planet with NO naturally occurring human residents — and as such, it really ought to be left alone. These controls are a good start.

  • http://www.mongolrallyguys.com Scott

    I went to Antarctica in 2006 as a part of a small expedition.

    While we were there we were treated to talks by local scientists and experts on many aspects of the continent. One thing that was generally agreed upon by everyone was that there have been big changes in the last few decades.

    I was lucky enough to be on a 75-passenger ship–most tourists are not. I would have to say that most ships we saw were huge ocean liners that had about a 400-passenger capacity.

    It’s getting to the point where people go just to go and say they’ve done it–they really don’t care about any ecological aspects of the area they’re visiting.

  • http://wayworded.blogspot.com/ Hal

    Me too, Lola. Let’s sneak down there while no one’s looking. ;)

  • http://www.asianramblings.com Stevo

    Bravo. This looks like a great initiative. Tourism in Antarctica should be limited. I doubt the tour companies will agree. I’ll agree with another commenter: It’s a trip that should be earned.

  • Pingback: Antarctica Time lapse: A Year on Ice

  • Pingback: Antarctica Flights: Australian Sidetrip?

  • Pingback: mekuria getinet | new media designer » Photo Essay: 18 Places to Feel Dwarfed by Nature #photography

  • Pingback: 18 places that make you feel small | weeklypop

  • Rusha

    I think this is just the U.S. trying to control more of the world. Manifest Destiny and such. It’s crap.

  • Pingback: Antarctica Shoot

Activism + Politics →

Matador interviews Paul Sanchez-Navarro Russell, director of Centro Ecologico Akumal in...

Sustainability →

Together with National Geographic, Epicocity is raising awareness about an ecosystem...

Sustainability →

The New York Times reports that plunging real estate prices represent a "green lining" in...

Sustainability →

Christmas isn't the only winter holiday that's going green.

Sustainability →

Online Education breaks down everything you need to know about bottled water in a few...

Activism + Politics →

Tim DeChristopher's answer will take him all the way to court.

Sustainability →

I'll admit, this isn't the first thing you want to read this morning.

Sustainability →

Environmental and social justice activist Majora Carter sets up a false opposition.

Activism + Politics →

The average person in the US receives 11 pieces of junk mail per week. How many trees...

Sustainability →

The best green shows on television. (Hint: We're not in Wild Kingdom anymore.)

Activism + Politics →

New solar thermal plants in the Mojave desert are leading the way towards US energy...