Previous Next

These days, when I travel to Detroit it’s mostly for football games or funerals.

I suppose it’s odd to call myself a “traveler” to Detroit, the place where I was born and where I lived until I was 22.

Actually, let me take that back. I was born in a Detroit hospital; however, I grew up in the suburbs, and in my entire life have probably only spent a total of a few days below 8 Mile Road — yes, that is a real road, not just the name of the movie about Eminem.

Even when I fly to Detroit, I don’t actually enter the city. My plane lands at Detroit Metro airport, which is in Romulus, and then I take a taxi to my mother’s house, in the northwest suburbs, where I grew up. If there’s a football game, we drive to Ann Arbor. If there’s a funeral, we go to the cemetery in Birmingham.

Last summer, I was surprised to hear a friend of mine in New York tell me that he’d gone to Detroit for the weekend with his boyfriend. On a vacation.

And they’d enjoyed it.

I’ve been reading about artists moving to the city, to take advantage of Detroit’s low rents and about plans to turn Detroit’s vacant lots into a network of local, organic farms.

“But what did you do there?” I asked, incredulous.

They’d gone to the Detroit Institute of Arts and the Motown Museum, and they’d had brunch at the Whitney, a restored historic mansion.

“Detroit’s great,” he raved.

As a Southeast Michigan native, I’m completely baffled by others’ fascination with my hometown, the very same one which I and all three of my brothers were only too eager to leave for “real” cities like Chicago or Washington, DC or New York. And yet, according to Chrysler ads featuring Eminem and Clint Eastwood, Detroit is coming back.

(I wish I could believe it, but I’ve seen the Detroit-is-coming-back movie too many times.)

It’s true that the car industry has been doing better these days, thanks to the well-publicized government bailout. At the same time, I’ve been reading about artists moving to the city, to take advantage of Detroit’s low rents. I also keep hearing about plans to turn Detroit’s vacant lots into a network of local, organic farms.

In fact, Detroit’s state of ruin has become an industry in itself. The recent documentary Detropia took me on a gracefully shot tour of Detroit’s decaying grand edifices, while a hot new book, Detroit City Is the Place to Be: The Afterlife of an American Metropolis by Rolling Stone reporter (and my fellow University of Michigan alum) Mark Binelli, details the history of the city’s decline.

I was glad I saw Detropia, but I was even happier to have read Binelli’s book, which explains in detail a lot of the information that the movie presents in a more artistic but frustratingly elliptical style.

In addition to learning from Binelli’s careful research, I appreciated the candor with which he shared details of his experience growing up outside the city and looking in. Specifically, I found myself nodding in recognition when he wrote, “When I was growing up in the eighties, though, the riots were invoked with the compulsive regularity of a fresh grudge. This was in the suburbs, of course, where the grudge was not always expressed politely.”

Like many white kids of my generation who grew up in the suburbs, I too had heard my share of terrifying stories about the riots in Detroit, which I more than once heard referred to as “the jungle.”

Though my parents and their cohorts had all grown up there, they had never gone back to visit the streets where they used to walk to school or ride the trolley to shop at the flagship Hudson’s department store.

The few times we drove downtown to see a play, a baseball game, or an art exhibit, my father always made sure to lock all the car doors, and when we got off the highway, he’d sometimes run red lights to avoid stopping. Every time we passed under a bridge, I used to cringe, fearful that someone would drop a heavy rock onto the roof of our car.

All this took place more than 20 years ago, yet even in recent years, I’ve been at family gatherings where I’ve overheard well-meaning suburban parents and grandparents chastising their children for daring to sing the city’s praises. “Detroit,” they sigh and roll their eyes.

These things are not pleasant to confess, but they are important to confront and to try to understand. Because if there’s to be any hope of a genuine Motor City comeback, it will have to involve the people who live just beyond the city limits, the ones who, when asked where they’re from, pause just a little before answering, “Detroit. Well, not Detroit exactly, but…”



About The Author

Aaron Hamburger

Aaron Hamburger was awarded the Rome Prize by the American Academy of Arts and Letters for his short story collection THE VIEW FROM STALIN'S HEAD (Random House), also nominated for a Violet Quill Award. His next book, a novel titled FAITH FOR BEGINNERS (Random House), was nominated for a Lambda Literary Award. His writing has appeared in the New York Times, Poets and Writers, Tin House, Details, Michigan Quarterly Review, Boulevard, and the Village Voice. He has received fellowships from the Edward F. Albee Foundation and the Civitella Ranieri Foundation in Umbria, Italy, as well as residencies from Yaddo and Djerassi. He has also taught writing at Columbia University, NYU, and the Stonecoast MFA Program.

  • Rosemary Guzman Hook

    Wow — you captured the closet embarrassment most Michiganders have of Detroit. I haven’t read Binelli’s book but I just might buy it now. My hometown is Saginaw which continues to struggles to rebuild itself while I watch it from afar in Austin, TX. Saginaw is making progress but not quite in the metro cultural way that Detroit has been able to do by incorporating the art scene (Detroit Met by the way is impressive. The Diego Rivera mural alone is worth the visit.) I used to heard Detroit called Detoliet but not for a long time now.

You must leave your home and go forth from your country.
Guards said the only exit was through the chimney.
And so he does, of course, and is immediately transported far beyond his cluttered desk,...
When the advisories go out, when the chairlifts shut down because of wind, and the chain...
She cursed us down, insulted us openly, and slammed the door behind her.
MaryLuck and her mother were in search of some sort of healing from the unknown.
I have no choice but to trust my friends and the movement of the planet and to get on...
What I learned was that far from empty, Patagonia is a peopled landscape.
“Can you write?” She shook her head. “Do you want to?” “Of course.” Her...
“You ever worked in a mine?” I’m caught off guard at his sudden question.
I feel the word weigh on my shoulders, but I’m powerless and silent.
Someone's timed it perfectly enough to give me a headful of post-explosion tinnitus.