Why NOT to study abroad in Western Europe
Feature Photo: wili_hybrid
I’LL FESS UP – I studied abroad in Aix-en-Provence, France, an emblem of the European study abroad experience with it’s idyllic stone fountains, sidewalk cafe culture, boutiques, bright photogenic markets, and pigeon-filled plazas.
I don’t regret it; it was my first time overseas and I squeezed every inch of experience out of it. I took a week-long bike trip from Aix through the Camargues (Provençal cowboy territory). I hiked across the island of Corsica and labored for half a summer in a French vineyard. I smacked my tooth into a plaza in Naples and drove to the furthest tip of Sicily. Travel was planted in me and hasn’t stopped growing like ravenous ivy ever since.
But if I could recommend a study abroad experience to someone else, it wouldn’t be in Europe.
Now that I’ve traveled and lived so many other places, I understand how easy that experience was. I studied entirely in French at the Institut des Etudes Politiques, but there was always English in the background just in case; the culture, while stunningly different to me when I arrived, was navigable and familiar enough to get a feel for; the food was different enough to glamorize but not so different that it produced late night, sleepless cheese cravings.
More importantly, the school (the University of Wisconsin-Madison) set the whole thing up and walked students through it in baby steps. If I could go back in time, I’d use all that organizational help and power to go someplace which is extremely difficult to navigate bureaucratically and institutionally on one’s own – someplace, say, like Senegal, or China.
I’d like to study in these places now, but the prospect of negotiating my way alone through the Chinese university system (something which another university, this time one I was teaching for, did for me in 2007) is daunting at best.
Having professionals guide you through the process of studying and living abroad eliminates a massive bureaucratic and technical headache.
If you’re already paying tuition at a university, then studying abroad in South Africa or East Asia is like a free ticket through all the complicated hoops you’d need to jump on your own in order to set yourself up with a life in one of those places.
Then there’s the personal growth factor. Did I grow in Western Europe? Did France change me? Yes. Did it rock my world, shake the foundations of my cultural assumptions and beliefs? No. It gave me an appreciation for the little things. As Europe has so often done for Americans, it fine-tuned my senses and made me realize how much I was rushing around from stimulation to stimulation in a progress-driven frenzy.
But in comparison to the enormous blow to my ego and worldview that was one day in Beijing, that year in Western Europe was an afternoon drinking wine in the park. Same with South America. My travels there were of a very different nature than anything you’d do on most study abroad programs – I crossed the continent alone, on buses, with a budget of wads of horded coffee shop tips. I camped most of the time and hiked Patagonia on oatmeal, pasta and alfajores. Sure, it’s unfair to compare this with what’s possible within the limits of a university program.
But the experiences and the awareness of different histories, circumstances and worldviews I got out of that trip so superseded those of my year in France that I can only wonder about what I might’ve thought, done, or attempted had my first experience abroad been in Lima or Caracas.
I spent those seven months in South America testing the boundaries of my daring and independence and exploring ways to get immersed in places, to get as far from my comfort zone as possible, to connect with people of vastly different cultural backgrounds. I realized I hadn’t pushed myself that far in France because it wasn’t as necessary. South America challenged me far more than France ever had.
This isn’t to say that study abroad in Latin America or Africa or Central Asia is an automatic porthole to mind-blowing travel breakthroughs. And it isn’t to say that Western Europe is incapable of stirring up such breakthroughs, or that it isn’t important or worth seeing.
But I think that if your first immersion travel experience is someplace other than Seville or London, it might have an entirely different impact. It might shape the way you see the world in more profound, troubling, and lingering ways.
The number one thing study abroad in France taught me was that there are infinite opportunities to do whatever insane thing you’re thinking about doing. Before leaving for France, I wouldn’t have ever considered living in a vineyard and working 10 hours a day to pay for a hike across Corsica. I would have thought it virtually impossible to drive a van from Cairo to Capetown, or to bike across Patagonia.
After that year, I know that if I really want to go live in Rwanda, if I really want to teach in Japan or to ride a motorcycle through Cambodia, I can do it. I’m not wealthy – I am extremely fortunate to be in good health and to have the personal and political freedom to travel if I want. I’ve paid for every travel adventure I’ve ever had by working or saving.
So my realization of the magnitude of opportunities for travel wasn’t simply a realization that I could spend money roaming continents or dappling in exoticism; it was the realization that I didn’t need to have tons of money or privilege to travel.
I think going someplace that is not Western Europe would reinforce this realization tenfold. It seems unfathomable to many Americans to walk across East Africa, or to live and study in a small Chinese village. Studying abroad makes this seem possible, and the realm of possibilities just keeps expanding. If you start out with an opportunity that seems frightening and difficult to fathom, imagine how vast the possibilities could seem afterwards.
Finally, and most importantly, the U.S needs people with empathy and understanding of regions outside of Western Europe.
Studying abroad is one of the easiest and most powerful ways to create consciousness of the way people think and live in many different areas of the world.
Immersing yourself in cultures that are poorly understood, feared, or dismissed in the U.S can make a world of difference in creating a more compassionate and informed future generation.
Sarah Menkedick
Matador Contributing Editor Sarah Menkedick has traveled, lived, and taught on five continents, and is constantly in pursuit of spicy food, dark beer, and new places to run. She is an MFA student at the University of Pittsburgh.
More By This Author
- Final week to apply to the Glimpse Correspondents Program
- Announcing the Spring 2012 Glimpse Correspondents! (1 comments)
- Application deadline for Glimpse Correspondents Program extended




This article really hit home for me. I am a college student soon to embark on study abroad to Thailand and some surrounding countries, and all I have heard are remarks about safety and comparisons to my friends studying in Western Europe. This article clearly explained my reasons for going abroad somewhere I would not feel comfortable going alone.
I understand both sides of this ongoing argument, however it surely comes down to the person going abroad. Some Americans are completely happy in their clubbing and drinking visions of the common Western European study abroad experience. And that is that. I believe that if someone knows they want to travel in the future, they will choose to study somewhere less common, maybe a little unsafe, though mostly unknown. They wouldn’t want to wait to explore more distant lands, and would do so while in College.
I would think most of the visitors to this website, who read articles like this in spare time, would be more understanding of the benefits of being guided through drastically unknown territory, and how lucky it is to have that knowledgeable guide. Otherwise one may never have that experience in fear of going it alone.
Of course, the most important thing is to put yourself into another culture, at least for a moment, and widen your horizons as far as you wish.
Great article! Since studying abroad in Rome, Italy I have traveled to China, throughout Central and South America and I am currently living in Mexico City. My study abroad experience was my first real independent travel experience and my first time leaving the U.S. These days I enjoy living in Mexico City, but I tend to think that if Mexico City had been my very first travel/ living abroad experience the culture shock might have been too much. Sometimes it’s not a bad idea to take things one step at a time. It all depends, of course, on the individual, as does the travel experience itself. Either way, it’s great to see that this article has encouraged such an interesting debate!
Sarah
I just wanted to say great article, and I really do agree. I did my first study abroad in Senegal actually (funny that you mentioned that one) and my second one in Malta. In both experiences I had to relearn everything from how to go to the toilet properly to dealing with so-called “Mediterranean mentality”. I loved the challenge of living in these places and feel like I’ve gained a strong understanding of simply how to navigate and adapt to unexpected circumstances or ways of thought. I also think that learning the process itself is applicable to trying to understand Western Europe, and, honestly, since both countries were former colonies, I was given the chance go understand Western Europe from a post-colonialist perspective as well. Sure, the trip I took around Western Europe after leaving Malta felt so incredibly easy, but at the same time it meant I had to invent more and more creative ways to go about it, which included trying to see the connections between, well, everywhere.
Anyways, thank you for putting this bit of advice out there, because I would say the same.
I just read this article and can see both sides of the argument. In two weeks I will be going to Spain for a immersion program through my school for Spanish. Being said that, I will be volunteering with the immigrants from Morocco and Algeria. I think that Western Europe was generalized in this piece, but that is alright. In France there are plenty of French-Algerians that aren’t considered part of the “French” culture, but they are. For people that want a different experience in these “countries” that is so American like, then look for the minority populations and see how they are living in that environment.
I can see the flip side as well. There seems to be a large number of Americans, only saying this because I am american, who travel to Western Europe for a good time. But from what I have been hearing is to not be around these people. You make your experience what it is.
I have been to Jamaica and South Africa on study abroad and look forward to a “European” experience. Being that I am also black, my experience will be different from my fellow white and asian students.
Good Article overall!
I think for sure, the biggest difference between studying abroad in Western Europe and anywhere else is the cultural aspect, the non-”western” viewpoints that are taught in daily life. Also, I think people who want to go to Europe to experience a different culture are looking for different answers in their curiosities versus those who decide to go to Asia instead. Of course, there isn’t a true right answer but certainly the best way would be to experience all if not as much of it as you can.
Thanks for this article! Studying anywhere in abroad is really a life changing experience; but as for me, I don’t really care if the university’s the best… as long as I enjoy the environment. don’t get me wrong, I do accept change, and I love it. but there’s this gut feeling that if I like the environment, no matter how “unsafe” or “boring” it is, I’d go for it.
I also did a post, “Why I Never Considered USA for Graduate Study” here: http://anthroonfoot.blogspot.com/.
Hope you could also share your insights